9 Natural Makeup Removers that Melt Away Stubborn Eye Makeup

These formulas are effective and also nourishing for the sensitive skin around your eyes.

We’re told over and over again to not leave our makeup on overnight. But the truth is, having to scrub off all that makeup when our comfy beds are only footsteps away can be a chore. What’s more, makeup removers from your neighborhood supplier aren’t exactly the most forgiving on your delicate skin. We’ve all had our share of removers that dry out our skin, make us lose a few lashes, or worse—that simply don’t work.

That’s where a natural makeup remover comes in. We’re talking about a soothing formula that easily melts stubborn makeup from your face—without any harsh chemicals or synthetic ingredients you can’t pronounce. Here are the top natural makeup removers that will actually have you looking forward to cleansing your face at the end of the day.

Best natural makeup removers

Vitamin B Enzyme Cleansing Oil + Makeup Remover from One Love Organics
Cruelty-free
How do you get rid of makeup without also clearing away important oils and nutrients that sustain your skin? By using a deluxe cleansing oil with hardworking fruit enzymes. This oil-based makeup remover harnesses papaya oil and enzymes to dissolve makeup and leave skin ultra soft. Vitamin E helps to balance skin by healing acne and damaged skin. No need to rinse, as this cleanser repairs your acid mantle and balances pH. After massaging into skin, simply sweep away makeup and let the formula nourish your skin. You’ll be left with toned, radiant skin.

Blood Orange Cleansing Balm from 100% Pure
Cruelty-free, gluten-free
If you love wearing glam makeup looks, this remover is your new go-to. It has a heavenly scent that’s reminiscent of a creamsicle, but it’s actually the blood orange essential oil! The organic coconut oil and olive oil dissolve stubborn eye makeup (yes, even waterproof mascara!) with gentle massaging, leaving skin supple and glowing. Blood orange is rich in antioxidants that protect and repair skin. A little goes a long way! The texture of this balm is super soft. Just a small amount of it melts into a luxe oil once applied to skin. Simply wipe away the balm after use, and rinse face with warm water.

Ocean Cleanser from Osea
Cruelty-free, vegan
Not quite a fan of rich plant oils? This gel cleanser uses light sesame seed oil and jojoba oil to sweep away makeup. The base of organic algae extract deeply hydrates skin. Lactic acid that’s naturally derived from beets gently exfoliates to clear away excess oil and dead skin cells, minimizing the appearance of pores.  It contains a blend of essential oils that freshen and brighten skin. Just apply to damp skin and massage to reveal clean, smooth skin. Rinse with warm water, and feel free to twice a day as your regular cleanser.

Nourishing Oil Cleanser from Tata Harper
Cruelty-free
Fighting rough or problem skin? It’s even more difficult to cleanse your skin when it’s inflamed or suffering from painful flakiness. This luxurious cleanser removes makeup with skin-friendly oils, while nourishing and repairing. Apricot kernel oil deeply penetrates skin, so that it nourishes with essential fatty acids without leaving skin feeling greasy. Alfalfa and calendula extract soothe sensitive skin. Using a cotton ball, apply this cleanser to dry skin—even your lashes—and massage. Rinse with water or follow with a clarifying cleanser.

Clarity Organic Makeup Remover from Vapour Organic Beauty
USDA organic, cruelty-free
You might be surprised at how fresh an oil cleanser can leave your face, even if you have oily skin. Vapour has carefully crafted a formula that won’t clog pores, so people with acne-prone or oily skin can rest assured. This certified organic makeup remover contains non-comedogenic sunflower seed oil that’s also anti-bacterial. The rest of the plant oils are also light and fast-absorbing. Vapour has thoughtfully chosen a blend of herbal extracts to help calm inflamed skin.

Makeup Remover from Derma E
Cruelty-free, vegan, gluten-free
This oil-free formula is a dream for acne-prone or oily skin types, as well as for people with sensitive skin that’s easily irritated by oil-based ingredients. The gentle formula is especially effective for eye makeup removal (it even contains Provitamin B5 and green tea extract to help nourish eyelashes!). Once applied with a cotton pad around the eye area, it’s able to sweep away waterproof mascara, eyeliner, and dirt. Cucumber and chamomile extract help soothe inflammation and calm redness.

Image credit: Ursa Major

Essential Face Wipes from Ursa Major
Cruelty-free, vegan, gluten-free
For those of you always on-the-go, whether it’s getting to the gym after work or going on your next business trip, these disposable makeup wipes are your savior. They loosen up makeup and sweep away sweat for a refreshed complexion. These wipes won’t ever dry out skin, thanks to the base of soothing aloe vera and moisturizing hyaluronic acid. Willow bark and rosemary help fight bacteria for balanced skin. Just wipe across your face for an immediate cleanse without the hassle.

The Ultimate Makeup Remover Wipes from RMS Beauty
Cruelty-free
Drugstore makeup wipes are notorious for containing skin-drying alcohols and synthetic ingredients that do more harm than good for skin. These makeup wipes from RMS Beauty bring things down to earth by featuring just one hero ingredient to do the job. You heard that right, these makeup remover wipes contain only organic coconut oil in them! Coconut oil works to clear away makeup gently, since it’s naturally antimicrobial and an effective moisturizer.

Cleansing Milk from Juice Beauty
Cruelty-free
Have sensitive skin, but don’t want to settle with a subpar makeup remover? This cleanser deep cleanses skin with antioxidant-rich plant oils such as sweet almond oil and grapeseed oil. They’re light and soothing, and moisturizing enough for mature or dry skin. Anti-inflammatory chamomile and calendula help to tone skin. And check out the blend of Vitamin B5, Vitamin C, and Vitamin E that condition lashes and provide anti-aging benefits. Massage this cleanser into skin to remove makeup and purify skin.

Looking for more ways to clean up your beauty routine? You might get some useful tips from these beauty guides:

Best Face Washes for Oily Skin: How to battle that gunk and feel refreshed with the best face washes for oily skin.
Why a Konjac Sponge Should Be a Part of Your Cleansing Routine: Could a sponge actually help balance your skin? Here’s why konjac sponges are a skin care hack.